The anniversary decorations were still up. Gold ribbon. White roses. Photographs of my parents smiling through decades of staged happiness arranged on the entry table. In one frame my mother wore a silver dress and my father looked young enough for hope. In another, Tyler and I stood between them at some long-forgotten holiday, already old enough for the family roles to have hardened. Jace wore his favorite expression even then—that easy self-satisfaction people mistake for charisma until it starts costing them money.

The foyer tiles shone.

The dining room table glittered.

The kitchen island still held half-empty platters and a row of wineglasses with lipstick stains on the rims.

And by the trash can near the pantry, shoved down under paper napkins and aluminum foil, was the smashed remains of the cake I had brought the night before.

I stopped.

It had taken me three hours to make that cake.

Vanilla sponge with citrus zest because my mother used to pretend, when guests were around, that lemon was her favorite. Buttercream done by hand because the mixer in the basement kitchen nook had been broken for six months and nobody cared enough to replace it. A simple sugar decoration at the top. No bakery label. No prestige. Just effort. The kind of effort families are supposed to understand as love even when it arrives without frosting roses and ribboned boxes.

She had thrown it away like I had handed her garbage.

Helena stepped into the kitchen behind me and followed my gaze to the trash.

Her expression changed, very slightly.

“Homemade?” she asked.

“Yes.”

She stood there a moment longer, then said, “I take back every charitable thought I almost had.”

That got a sound out of me after all. A short laugh, sharp as broken glass.

We went downstairs.

The basement stairs had always smelled faintly damp no matter the season. Three years of bleach, dehumidifiers, and careful cleaning had never quite beaten back the mildew in the walls. The ceiling was low enough that Jace used to joke I belonged down there with the spiders and storage bins. My parents called it an apartment whenever they wanted to sound generous to outsiders and “the basement” whenever they wanted to remind me where I ranked.