Renata arrived three minutes later with a canvas bag, a legal pad, and that same focused stillness good social workers carry when they know the room they are entering will require both softness and backbone.
“Has anyone else spoken to her since your call?” she asked.
“Only me and James.”
“Good.”
I went back inside the bay and asked Brooke if she would be willing to speak with a social worker. I explained what that meant, what would be documented, who would read it, and what would happen next might partly depend on whether she wanted the truth on record tonight.
She listened carefully.
“Will you stay outside the curtain?” she asked.
“Yes.”
“Then okay.”
Renata spent forty minutes with her. I stood outside the curtain for all forty, hands clasped behind my back, not because I was powerless but because holding still was the most useful form of power then. Francis sat at the end of the hallway with my notes open on her phone, occasionally making small sounds of professional appreciation or disgust.
At the twenty-minute mark she looked up and said quietly, “Entry thirty-seven. The one where you wrote, ‘Possible. Also possible not.’ Keep that exact phrasing. Judges trust witnesses who leave room for uncertainty.”
“I had no intention of editing.”
“Good.”
When Renata finally stepped out, she did not need to dramatize anything. The truth had enough weight on its own.
“Her account is detailed, consistent, and credible,” she said. “Pattern of escalating physical intimidation and force beginning shortly after the marriage. Tonight is not isolated. Mother has witnessed at least part of the behavior on multiple occasions. Child reports phone restrictions, social isolation, monitored communications, and reduced access to extended family.”
“Will you file tonight?” Francis asked.
“I already started the paperwork in the car. It’ll be submitted within the hour.”
“Good,” Francis said. “I’m petitioning first thing.”
Then James appeared again, chart in hand, face tighter than before.
“I need both of you for one more piece.”
He led us into a side consult room and pulled up the imaging.
“This is tonight’s fracture,” he said, indicating Brooke’s distal radius. “Hyperextension, as discussed. But on the lateral view, here—” He zoomed. “There’s evidence of a healed distal ulna fracture in the same arm. Approximately six to nine months old. Untreated.”